Outside of the main hymn, the remaining thematic material
in
The Hunt for Red October exists in mostly simple motifs of
harmoniously elegant chord progressions. One of the better developed
motifs exists in the form of a graceful choral movement for the title
submarine itself, used repeatedly during underwater shots of the ship's
movements. The crescendo heard in "Course Two-Five-Zero" is a teaser for
the ballet-like sways of "Red Route I," during which the ease with which
the massive sub navigates treacherous depths is given an almost
effortless poise and flow. While the choral majesty of "Course
Two-Five-Zero" and "Red Route I," as well as the curious variant of the
hymn for a more pensive choir in "Ancestral Aid," have the most dramatic
impact on the film's visual beauty, Poledouris' action material has a
far more technologically cold side to its precision. As in many of the
composer's works, rhythm is key to
Red October, launching cues
like "Nuclear Scam" and "Kaboom!!!" with unabashed vigor and attitude.
Many of the same sound effects that Poledouris would use in
Free
Willy and his other intelligent synthetic/orchestral combo scores
were utilized in full for
Red October. The early cue, "Putin's
Demise," offers the methodical rhythmic incorporation of the upper
ranges of these keyboarded effects, while the brilliantly paced
evacuation sequence in "Nuclear Scam" shifts this application to a
lengthy, nearly solo portion in the lower ranges of the same effect.
Many of Poledouris' other effects utilized sounds manipulated for
underwater imitation or pressurized air release. For instance, the most
obvious sound effect used by Poledouris in
Red October is an
echoing synth orchestra hit that bounces between the left and right
front speakers, dissipating like an underwater signal bouncing through
the ship and mirroring the ping-like variant used as a sound effect in
the film. An interesting, but barely noticeable sound effect in the
score is the use of a "release of air" sound heard at the end of
"Putin's Demise," though it's not as clearly audible in subsequent cues.
Some of the action sequences in
Red October feature a more
traditional set of synthetic aides, including the use of somewhat tired
drum pads in "Chopper" and "Kaboom!!!." The latter track is evidence
that Poledouris was forced to abandon the orchestra in the later action
sequences due to disappearing recording funds; for the final battle
involving the Red October and two other submarines, Poledouris
approaches the cue from an almost completely synthetic approach,
recording nearly all of these cues by himself at his home studio.
While effective in the context of the action of
The
Hunt for Red October, the synthetic choral substitute in "Kaboom!!!"
is legitimate reason for dismay. The emergency surfacing of the American
submarine in this scene is given the best majesty that Poledouris can
muster given the tools at hand, but the cue, despite some good low-range
rhythmic pulsing later in the recording, is cheapened by the embellished
drum pads and fake orchestra hits. The lingering elements of minor
dissatisfaction involving the score for
Red October don't stop
there, either. Some of the work was removed from the film and several
other cues were arranged and inserted repeatedly where Poledouris
probably didn't intend them to be. As many as ten major cues were either
removed completely, such as the opening moments of the film that
featured silence instead, or cut short, including some of the score's
major action pieces. The dual-purpose scene depicting a discussion
between Sean Connery and Sam Neill about their personal lives,
interspersing shots of submarine navigation, replaced Poledouris'
original cue ("Two Wives") with one from the composer's
No Man's
Land, a McTiernan favorite. Some of the lesser conversational cues
utilized the limited orchestral time in the score rather than leaving
that session money for the important scenes at the end of the film. Even
the end credits features music consisted of a highly rearranged version
of "Nuclear Scam," the budget for Poledouris' more unique "New World"
cue for that conclusion not available. Listeners looking for answers to
questions about the
Red October score on its initial, woefully
short commercial album were not greeted kindly. The 30-minute album was
nothing short of a disgrace, partly due to the music not included in its
length, but mostly because of a truly terrible quality of sound that
fluctuates wildly from track to track. For a film with such glorious
surround mixes, including a superior presentation of the score's
recording in the movie,
Red October teases you with musical
creativity on screen that you were not destined to hear with the same
vibrancy on album. On that MCA product, Poledouris' recording is muffled
and dry, with poor balance between synthetic and orchestral, orchestral
and choral. That disservice is exactly what this finely tuned score does
not need, and if you read criticisms of
Red October's
score from other reviewers who don't appreciate all the hoopla about
this score, then rest assured that those writers probably haven't done
the necessary research into this massive difference in quality between
the film and album presentations.
Through the years, soundtrack collectors turned to a
bootleg with over an hour of music from
The Hunt for Red October
that began to surface a decade after the MCA product's debut. This
bootleg never solved many of the sound quality issues, however, which is
why an official 2013 Intrada Records expansion of the score on album was
so highly anticipated. This CD does offer the complete score with some
alternates (though not everything included on the bootlegs,
interestingly), and the highlights of the newly released material
gravitate towards the early, orchestral portions ("Tupolov"). The
illuminated late action and suspense cues reveal secondary rhythmic
devices that Poledouris relied upon to supply depth to the final cat and
mouse chasing game in the story, though these pulses are not as
satisfying apart from the film as other sequences. The late torpedo cue,
for instance, is rather sparse in its rendering. By contrast, the
earlier character-building scenes feature equally minimal but much more
interesting orchestral tones similar to what Michael Kamen provided to
the director's original
Die Hard. The 2013 album has a pair of
brutal flaws, however, that make it only a marginally recommended
product. First is the lack of improvement in sound quality. The score
still sounds muffled in much of its length, a result of the decision by
the album's producers not to attempt a full remastering of the score.
Apparently, Poledouris tweaked the complicated merging of orchestra,
synthesizer, and chorus so many times in his mixes that a recreation of
them from the separate elements was deemed too daunting. This choice,
while perhaps practical, dooms
Red October to mediocrity in its
album sound quality. The other flaw of the album is the poor attempt to
reassemble the end credits arrangement of the film for this product. For
many years, fans have taken this rearrangement of the title hymn and
"Nuclear Scam" from the DVD directly, and when you compare the DVD's
distilled stereo sound with that of the Intrada album, you'll be
astonished by the difference. Even the 2013 album's assembly of the "End
Credits" suite is inferior to what comes off the DVD in the finesse of
the fades between cues. Overall, having a muted mix of this score on
album completely defeats the purpose of the synthesizers' intentional
movements across the sonic spectrum, leaving Poledouris enthusiasts with
hearing the stylistic leftovers on the better presented
Free
Willy album from 1993. Still, historically,
Red October
stands alongside
Ice Station Zebra and
Crimson Tide as a
thoroughly enjoyable submarine score of immense popular appeal to its
generation. But until the lingering sound quality issues are finally
addressed, don't expect any album presentation to end years of
frustration for fans of the film.
@Amazon.com: CD or
Download