Therein lies the conundrum that is the soundtrack for
Gravity, music that strives to address a somewhat conventional
storytelling perspective through a dichotomy of sounds that don't always
make sense. In other words, if this is the score that Bullock's
character hears in her own head, then does all the nearly stifling
electronic manipulation of the music suggest that she is a robot
herself? Of course not. A person blinded by science and without a
romantic heart? Certainly not based on the story. A person delusional
because of fear? This is Price's only escape hatch, and he's counting on
the transformation of the score from one extreme (total sound design) to
another (absolute tonal bliss of a large scale) to reflect the
character's proximity to salvation. The word salvation is important in
this context, because Price also infuses a slight sense of religious
atmosphere to the score, whether in the application of a
broadly-conceived organ or vocals ranging from ethereal solos to the
outright gospel celebration at the end. Until the final minutes of the
score, though, Price is sure to bolster your feeling of alienation
through extremely unpleasant electronic manipulation of substantially
organic tones, an array of soloists recorded separately and altered
significantly until the pathos of the sound matches the abrasive nature
of the level of panic in each scene. Make no mistake about it;
Gravity is an extremely unpleasant listening experience apart
from the film, its prickly, forbidding, and distant demeanor reminiscent
of James Horner's
Vibes at its darkest, dominating all but a
ten-minute section of victorious music near the end when the major key
is afforded some breath. The idea of battling the design against the
traditional tonality and eventually shifting from one to the other is
excellent, and one can hear melodic development over time that will
vaguely remind of Trevor Jones, with whom Price has worked. To be
debated is whether Price sells out too far in either direction at the
beginning and end, opting not for subtlety in transformation but rather
outright transcendence not to be missed by a five-year-old. Given that
the entirety of the album for
Gravity is such a daunting
challenge to appreciate without trying to relive the film, it would be
interesting to study the design and tonal portions alone, separately, to
determine their merit outside of that brazen transformation. Some would
argue that such a separation of components would ultimately defeat the
entire point of the score, and they're probably right.
There is one aspect of
Gravity that can be
praised almost universally, and that is Price's ability to keep the
whole of the work from sounding derivative. There are individual usages
that are conventional and somewhat tired, such as the use of a heartbeat
effect through portions of the score to match the level of anxiety in
the main character. This, among other insertions in the mix, has a touch
of Ennio Morricone to it. Likewise, a fair number of the manipulations
can be traced back to other sources, the altered strings most
specifically. But none of these has a profoundly negative impact on the
score like the crescendo to a sudden out that plagues a number of cues
throughout the work. As obnoxious as backwards edits of organic sounds
can be, even they cannot compete with the massively irritating technique
of building a tone to a frenzy and then cutting it off suddenly. Price
does this at the end of countless cues in
Gravity, and it is a
cheap and unacceptable method of hitting a synchronization point that is
deserving of lesser films than this. The score opens with such a
dissonant buildup to silence and sets the stage for twenty minutes of
quite horrifying tones of despair. In "Don't Let Go," however, Price
does introduce shades of the main romantic theme for the film that would
eventually dominate the last three major cues. Fortunately, this
identity for Bullock's character is outstanding, evolving from vague
string and vocal shades to solo piano and eventually fully-expressed,
mostly easy orchestral harmony at the end. The secondary sequence in
this theme is downright lovely in its progressions. As mentioned before,
however, the tone of the vocals in "Gravity" is over the top, especially
when merged with the trumpet figures and other heroic devices. Those
seeking the accessible highlights of this score will want to explore the
final two cues despite continued manipulated passages in that material.
This is, in the end, a thinking person's score, one not meant for
enjoyment on album as much as analysis of technique. It's a great work
to review in a context like this, because it plays to topics of the
psyche and tradition that are debatable in a film such as Cuaron's. The
merits of the execution of the score's intent suggest four stars in
rating here, but the unacceptably obnoxious cut-off crescendos alone
(including the one to end the score) unfortunately reduce this score
back to a more average three-star middle. Function as well as it may at
times in the picture, this music, like that depiction as a whole,
suffers from a few logical fallacies, those for the score involving the
perspective from which it is supposed to be interpreted.
*** @Amazon.com: CD or
Download