The instrumentation of
Family Plot is really where
Williams' style for the picture distinguishes the score. The general
sound is definitely representative of the maestro, but like
Heartbeeps and a handful of others, the tone and solo emphases in
Family Plot really make it memorable. A large string section
offsets a truncated brass section, but the orchestra is almost always
employed in a secondary role to solo performances on woodwinds,
harpsichord, harp, or synthesizer. The many flute and other woodwind
passages bring what little convincing warmth to be gleaned from the
story, while the harpsichord is a decent extension of the wealth and
privilege suggested by the story. The harp provides the ambience of
mystery in several cues while the ARP synthesizer both carries the
motifs of the villains and maintains ominously harsh tones as a stinger
device. Timpani accents denote obvious gravity. The angelic women's
choir has a parody element to it here, though Williams collectors may
find its application to a couple of cues a foreshadowing of tones heard
with more sincerity in
Hook and
A.I. Artificial
Intelligence. While the composer utilized the harpsichord many times
at the height of his career, including
The Missouri Breaks and
Monsignor in that era, its dominance of the humorous character of
this score will draw the most comparisons to
The Witches of
Eastwick. The rhythmic flow of
Family Plot is split between
the upbeat harpsichord-led theme for the psychic and the base-region
rambling for the villains, the latter most resembling the propulsive
sense in
Black Sunday that would also foreshadow elements in the
future for Williams. Like the themes for
Family Plot, the
instrumental applications are proven malleable enough by Williams to
mingle significantly with disparate ideas to mirror the complex
relationships in the story. The themes themselves are also presented
often as counterpoint to each other or with fragments melded in
unexpected ways. You will rarely encounter a moment in
Family
Plot during which Williams isn't expressing at least one of his four
main themes for the film, and most cues muddy their development or tease
the audiences with merged meanings to suggest forthcoming plot
revelations. Unfortunately, none of the themes for this film is
particularly appreciable outside of context, Williams' obligatory
adaptation of the seance theme into a 70's light rock song an
interesting piece of testimony to the versatility of his ideas but
necessarily something you'd want to hear often for standalone enjoyment.
Like the cast on screen, the themes are truly an ensemble effort with no
clear highlight.
The first theme heard in
Family Plot is the one
for the psychic's seances, an identity better remembered for its use of
ethereal women's voices than the melody itself. Outside of the two
tracks indicating that application, it also bookends the "End Cast" cue
as necessary to suggest both a trance and the ultimate humor behind it.
As mentioned before, the "Family Plot Theme" pop adaptation is so
different in its treatment of the idea that they will seem unrelated to
casual listeners. The second theme, and more appropriately the main idea
for
Family Plot, is the one for the psychic's true, mischievous
personality. Represented by the harpsichord in "Blanche's Challenge" and
beyond, this theme on the surface may resemble
The Witches of
Eastwick in its most buoyant performances but actually, when boiled
down to solo piano or woodwind, carries some of the creepiness of
A.I. Artificial Intelligence as well, especially as the idea
morphs into a love theme in "Blanche and George." While this theme is
usually characterized by easy harmony and may represent the antics of
the protagonists well enough, it's often a bit obnoxious in its awkward
movements ("Kitchen Pranks" may be too much parody to handle). Far more
intriguing are the themes associated with the villains. The Shoebridge
theme (representing the family involving the heir) is a convoluted,
slowed, and mangled distortion of the Blanche theme in some ways, but
its distinctively warped progressions are quite adept at making subtle
connections between the villains and the family of the old woman seeking
to find her heir. The highlight of the score is ironically the outward
expression of criminal intent espoused by the Adamson theme for the
kidnapping ring. This rambling minor third rhythm is heard first in "The
Mystery Woman" and grows more intense as the plot progresses toward the
determination that the protagonists must be killed. The ARP synthesizer
conveys this theme most convincingly, with a raw sense of malice not
heard often in scores thirty years later. In terms of its progression,
the Adamson theme will be associated by younger listeners with the
suspense motif in
Jurassic Park, a musical association also made
in
Black Sunday (thus the prior mention of rhythmic connections)
and other subsequent scores. The idea is often used as the rhythmic
backdrop for the Shoebridge theme, the two of them usually flowing in
and out of each other (and may actually be confused as one overarching
villains' idea). While "The Mystery Woman," complete with driving snare,
is the longest full expression of these ideas together, their urgently
forceful resolve in "Nothing Held Back" is a brief but superior
highlight.
As the score for
Family Plot reaches its most
suspenseful scenes of confrontation involving the four remaining
characters, Williams shifts between the two villains' ideas and
Blanche's theme in very subtle environments. Rumbling piano comes to
define these slightly stated, overlapping themes for portions in
"Blanche's Arrival/Blanche's Note" and "Breaking Into the House" that
aren't particularly memorable. The final moment of decisive action in
"The Secret Door" loses the tension built in the rest of the score and
resolves rather tepidly, too. As such, the score doesn't really feature
any kind of satisfying resolution outside of the rotation between ideas
(and the translation of the Shoebridge theme into the major key) in "End
Cast." Overall, you can clearly understand and agree with the choices
Williams' made about treating
Family Plot with a lighter sound.
The thematic development is also precisely exercised and mingled with
skill. It's hard to argue with the instrumental choices, too. But this
score has always lacked the kind of impressive narrative flow that many
of Williams' other scores exhibit, absent the feeling of the inevitable
in
Black Sunday. Additionally, Blanche's harpsichord theme may
simply be too cute in its most extroverted form for some listeners. For
perhaps these reasons,
Family Plot has long remained John
Williams' most long-standing unreleased score, despite the pop
arrangement of the seance theme made specifically for the purposes of an
album. Bootlegs of the score have always featured incredibly poor sound
and the excerpts contained on compilations have never featured enough of
Williams' material for the story to give a well rounded impression of
its complicated thematic interactions. Finally, the Varèse
Sarabande label made
Family Plot the centerpiece of its late 2010
offerings in its CD Club, a product limited to a generous 5,000 copies.
The assembly of the score is the best possible, with the long source cue
"The Stonecutter," upwards of seven minutes featuring the absolute worst
of Williams' late-70's pop sensibilities, placed at the conclusion of
the album. Unfortunately, a superior source for the original recording
has never been located, and even despite the best efforts of the label
to engineer a dynamic soundscape from the three-track masters for
Family Plot, there is still an archival ambience to the entirety
of the score. Given the robust nature of especially the villains'
themes, this rather flat sound is a tragedy; the inherently dull tone of
the synthesizer doesn't help, either. Adding this note to all of the
aforementioned potential concerns for listeners,
Family Plot
isn't an automatic recommendation, a score aimed at collectors with an
intellectual appreciation of Williams' 1970's works. For causal
listening purposes,
Black Sunday would be a related and better
place to start an exploration of this sound.
*** @Amazon.com: CD or
Download