As Zimmer typically does these days, however, he leaves
several questions unanswered. One of the more intriguing debates film
score fans could have about
The Da Vinci Code is its tendency to
regurgitate "Zimmerisms" with the same frequency that James Horner
detractors would have debated endlessly had Horner teamed once again
with Howard for this project. Zimmer stays very close to his comfort
zone in
The Da Vinci Code, a project that, more than anything
else recently in his career, begged for an expansion of his horizons.
The instrumentation is predictable, with Zimmer replacing the presence
of brass with his own synthesizers. And while the construct of a cue
such as "Chevaliers de Sangreal" lends itself well to Zimmer's synthetic
string and brass samples, when you combine it with the adult chorus you
hear just too much
Crimson Tide to satisfy you in this entirely
different genre of film. Similarly obvious are the medium-range
churnings of strings both above and below the primary theme that are
saturated with styles from
Batman Begins. Additionally, the
score's overall effect on the listener, even after five or six listens
to the album, will lack enough creativity to sustain any interest
outside of the three or four very strong cues near the end of the score.
A few days after you hear the score several times repeatedly, you likely
won't recall a specific motif in your head (and if you can, then you're
truly a die-hard Zimmer fan). The slow tempo to the score contributes to
this disengagement, as does the predictability of the choral use and the
lackadaisical chord progressions of Zimmer's themes (the title shares
similarities to everyone's favorite, Trevor Jones'
Last of the
Mohicans, not to mention the rhythmic string origins that always
seem to come from the "Elk Hunt" cue from that score). Memorability
seems at a loss.
A disappointment in instrumental creativity also
hinders
The Da Vinci Code, aside from the unfortunate
substitution of synthesizers for brass, as happened in
Gladiator
too (if you hear the City of Prague Philharmonic or other group perform
that score, you'll note how much better a full brass presence
compliments Zimmer's style). The percussion section seems devoid of much
influence on the score either, which is also curious given the section's
capability of setting a stronger pace for a fast-moving story. Drums are
utilized, but the timpani range is often overshadowed by a droning mix
of real or synthetic bass strings that Zimmer often uses to infuse his
work with power. Once again, the "Chevaliers de Sangreal" cue comes to
mind, with the real percussion drowned out by synthetic rhythm samples
and the bass strings. Effective metallic percussion seems completely
lost on Zimmer here, with the one cymbal crash (the only one in the
whole score?) in the cue badly muted, and Zimmer's usual tolling bell
and clanging effects undermixed as well. These elements, when balanced
with the rest of the ensemble, produced fine results in
Crimson
Tide, but are poorly executed here. It should be mentioned that
Zimmer employs a tolling bell in "Rose of Arimathea" as the ending
punctuation to a dramatic cue, and it's easy to wish that Zimmer had
dipped further into that barrel of instrumental creativity elsewhere.
Also necessary to mention is the contribution of composer Richard
Harvey, who not only conducted the score, but also wrote the outstanding
choral piece "Kyrie for the Magdalene" that is heard in the film (on a
side note: given the quality of Harvey's other works, he likely would
have been capable of scoring this entire project brilliantly had he been
given the opportunity). Unfortunately not included in the picture is
Zimmer's enticingly lyrical "Salvete Virgines" choral cue that easily
distinguishes itself from the remainder of the score and solves the low
percussion mix that plagues the full ensemble pieces.
Because the story of
The Da Vinci Code is so
well loved, and opinions on its greatness can often be overblown, Zimmer
has unfortunately set himself up for a rash of criticism along the
"could have" and "should have" lines from listeners. His score suffices
at nearly every turn, flirting on excellence in places, but for what
stories is a sufficient score acceptable? Given the expectations, the
overall effect of his music here is ultimately underwhelming, due in
part to slow development, monotonous sequences, conservative
instrumentation, simplistic themes, and a questionable recording mix.
But if you accept those aspects of the music as parts of Zimmer's
palette to begin with, and you would enjoy a melting pot of motifs,
rhythms, and instrumentation from
Batman Begins,
Hannibal,
The Thin Red Line, and
Crimson Tide, then
The Da Vinci
Code will succeed for you. To say that could be greatly insulting of
Zimmer's talents, but a project like
The Da Vinci Code exposes
the best and worst of composers. It separates the men from the boys. And
even with all his ducks in a row and the wind at his back, Zimmer has
produced a score for
The Da Vinci Code that stands a head above
the boys, but a step below the men. The reason for this tough criticism
once again touches upon the problematic nature of Zimmer's approach to
Batman Begins. He has shown a tendency to adapt poorly to
situations that call for extreme creativity, writing music that pulls
the subject matter closer to his own comfort zone rather than throwing
his talents completely into the realm of the subject matter. Alas, we
get music for the sacred feminine that sounds like
Crimson Tide.
It would be difficult to say if James Horner could have done any better.
But you can't help but imagine what Thomas Newman, John Williams, or
Elliot Goldenthal could have written for
The Da Vinci Code. In a
world of secret messages and endless layers of meaning, Zimmer hasn't
yet proven that he can match such composers in intellectual approaches
to such a genre. His resume doesn't include Newman's
Angels in
America or any of the challenging textural ideas that would have
made Goldenthal such a delicious choice for
The Da Vinci Code.
Luckily, the film's story is so strong that it won't need the score to
support it, and Zimmer's music is, at the very least, inoffensive. On
album, apart from any idea of the film it accompanies, we hear some of
Zimmer's best material in years. Sometimes even the best inspiration can
be misdirected, though, and Zimmer is dangerously close to Vangelis
territory in these regards.
@Amazon.com: CD or
Download